Pizza restaurants

Ficarella's Pizzeria

4.1 458 reviews 03:00 PM - 10:00 PM 21 Liberty St #3238, Batavia, NY 14020, United States

Discover this place

Ficarella's Pizzeria, located in Batavia, NY, has garnered enthusiastic reviews that celebrate its outstanding pizza and welcoming service. Many customers, like Frances Jason, profess their love for Fic's pizza, praising the perfect balance of toppings such as pepperoni, mushrooms, and onions, emphasizing that it tastes even better the next day.

Cat Lash highlights the impressive consistency and unique offerings, such as pickle pizza and Buffalo chicken pizza, making Ficarella’s her go-to spot. The drive-thru service is a game-changer, providing quick access to delicious wings that, while flavorful, could benefit from a bit more heat, typical of Western New York fare.

Terry Barber reminisces about the authentic taste of northeastern pizzerias, praising the generous portions and the friendly staff willing to recommend local restaurants for variety. Daniel Snavely's experience of waiting for a freshly made pizza filled with rich toppings underscores the care put into each order.

Overall, Ficarella's Pizzeria stands out as a true culinary staple in Batavia, promising fresh, delicious pizza that caters to various preferences, including gluten-free options, ensuring a satisfying dining experience for families and friends alike.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Delivery
Drive-through
Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights

Serves local specialty

Popular for

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Lunch
Dinner
Catering
Counter service
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities

Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual

Crowd

College students
Family-friendly
Groups
Tourists

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Ficarella's Pizzeria before visiting.

Reviews for Ficarella's Pizzeria

4.1

458 reviews

100%

34%

11%

22%

Review highlights

Based on 458 reviews

Ficarella's Pizzeria in Batavia, NY, is widely appreciated for its consistently high-quality pizzas that balance fresh, flavorful toppings and generous portions. Customers frequently highlight the distinctive and well-crafted specialty pizzas, such as the pickle and Buffalo chicken varieties, as standout offerings. The pizzeria is praised for its authentic, nostalgic pizza experience reminiscent of traditional northeastern styles, with a particular emphasis on fresh ingredients and well-prepared crusts. Service is consistently described as friendly and attentive, contributing to a welcoming atmosphere. Minor delays in preparation are generally seen as worthwhile given the overall taste and quality. Overall, Ficarella’s is recognized for delivering reliable, satisfying meals that keep patrons coming back.

Frances Jason

Jul 22, 2025

No pizza in Batavia is anywhere near as good as Ficcs pizza. If I could eat it for every meal I would. It’s almost even better the next day. I like to load my pizza up with pepperoni, mushroom and onion and the ratio is perfect. Nothing is overpowering anything else. 10/10 every time, not to mention the service is always amazing. Everyone is so nice.

Cat Lash

Jul 15, 2025

There are a lot of pizza places in Batavia. Some great and some mediocre. What makes Ficarella’s my go to pizza place in town is how consistent they are. Their pickle pizza and Buffalo chicken pizza are definitely the stars of the show in my book. I can always count on my food being fresh and made how I expect it to be made. It’s made in a timely manner. Service in the store has been consistent, fast, professional, and positive in my many experiences with them. You also can’t beat the drive thru - pizza and wings in the drive thru is just genius. The wings are good, I order them well done to ensure they are crispy and very flavorful and never disappointing. The wings could be hotter but that’s WNY for you. The gluten free pizza is quite good (for being gluten free haha) they let you get specialty pizzas on a gluten free crust without charging outrageous amounts for each individual topping, I don’t know any other place that does that in WNY. My kids and husband like the regular pizza, they report that fic’s is never stingy on the cheese like many places. Over all I think this place is worth not just a visit but many return visits. A true staple! On the occasions we have gotten delivery it has been fast with very friendly drivers.

Terry Barber

Jun 30, 2025

Reminisce the way pizza is supposed to taste. Portion sizes for land locked giants and hungry patrons. Staff were very friendly and even referred other restaurants in the area for other cuisine options. I was immediately taken back to memory lane for northeast pizzerias that bring you in from the cold and warm you up with cheesy and freshly baked crust. Pepperonis were real and sausage was super flavorful. I will visit again and bring the wife as she loves Italian cuisine

Daniel Snavely

May 23, 2025

I was hoping to grab a quick slice but there was only one slice of pepperoni available. Instead I decided to order a small pizza with mushrooms, peppers, onions, and sausage. Took about 20 minutes but was well worth the wait. Very tasty